These CL Discussions are imagined conversations between a conservative Christian and a liberal person. The conservative’s name is Charles. The liberal’s name is Larry. These are not real conversations. They are imagined and the conservative views are mine, a fact you would have had no trouble discerning yourself. The opinions of the Liberal are typical of people I have met over the years, but don’t reflect any one person’s point of view. I am not claiming that these discussions are unbiased. I’m using them as a means of organizing my own thoughts as well as possibly helping others clarify their own point of view as well.
(Check for further conversations like this on Fridays. Whenever I have a CL discussion, I’ll post it on Friday.)
C: Yesterday you said that there is nothing that is absolutely right or absolutely wrong. Would you agree that it is wrong for a man to break into a home and rape a 4 year old girl?
L: Of course.
C: Should it be absolutely wrong in France?
C: Should it have been wrong in 1705 in Sudan?
L: Well, I don’t know what their culture was like.
C: So you can visualize a civilization where it might be acceptable to rape a young girl?
L: Yes, but I’m not saying it would be right. I’m saying that maybe that culture would think it was right.
C: But would they be right or wrong to have such a practice as a normal and accepted practice in their culture?
L: Since they are self-determining I guess it would be ok.
C: If such a thing were going on today in some country and you had the opportunity to intervene, would you?
L: Of course.
C: Even if that culture was fine with the practice?
L: I would intervene, because I think that even though the culture is fine with it, it seems abusive to me and so I would try to stop it if I could.
C: Why is abuse wrong?
L: It just is.
C: Who said so.
L: Everybody know that. It’s internal.
C: Not everybody knows it because some people are abusive. Some people may even have fun being abusive.
L: They’re probably lunatics. You know what I’m saying. Most people realize that abuse is wrong and oppose it.
C: So it’s wrong because most people have a sense it shouldn’t be happening and should be stopped?
L: That’s right
C: What if most people have a conscience that babies shouldn’t be killed while they are still in their mother’s womb? What if they think that is abusive of the baby?
L: The mother’s right supersedes the baby’s right.
C: So if it’s in my best interest to be abusive of a 4 year old, that is fine because I’m older and stronger?
L: No, we were talking about an unborn baby.
C: So the day before a baby is born, the mother has the right to take its life, but a day later after the baby moves from inside the mother to the outside, then at that point it takes on the right not to be killed? That doesn’t make any sense to me.
L: But that’s the way it is. Before a baby is born, the mother has a right to an abortion. But after the baby is born, it has its own rights.
C: Is that absolutely true?
C: Here we go again. I thought there was nothing that is absolutely true.